Wasn't the Yamato-class barbette that we test-fired and put a hole in done by a 16" 45? Answer (1 of 33): I would like to expand on some previous answers and offer one or more rebuttals on others: SHELLS - The North Carolina, South Dakota, and Iowa battleship classes all fired the "super-heavy" (2,700#) Mk 8 shells and using 660# of propellant. Naval History and Heritage Command Photo ID 80-G-K-101. The Iowa was the most-modernized battleship in the world in WW2. The Iowa Class main guns were figured to be able to penetrate the Yamatos. Going from Colorado to North Carolina back in the day was a night and day playstyle. USS Washington and its sister, North Carolina, were the first American battleships built since 1921. This plus good optics and there's a better chance that North Carolina (plus South Dakota and Iowa class, unsure if the WW1 dreadnoughts had the upgrade) will hit her targets more often than Yamato will. Yeah, another question about on the way thereâ¦, Idk, I kind of want to make a Nagato secondary build now. Saying it may badly damage them it no way implies it has to get lucky to do this. Article by Battleship NORTH CAROLINA. Free en.wikipedia.org. U.S. These developed 150,000 shp and could drive the ship at a top speed of 27 knots. However the Iowa should be able to hit the Yamato over the horizon and while both ships could penetrate the others deck at over 35k the much superior American radar would have told heavily. The Yamato was supposed to withstand 16" shells. Explores The Once Most Feared And Famous Warships That Carry Powerful Guns And Were Fitted With More Armor Than Other Warships. Found insideFramed by a 5-inch gun and a crewmember of an escorting destroyer, USS North Carolina is seen here in May 1941 during her shakedown cruise. From a tonnage perspective, a Yamato is ~2x a North Carolina. Yamato Battleship vs Montana Class BattleShip. Yamato would miss, North Carolina would have a new firing solution, and would land another volley. The concept of the Yamato class is a single battleship which is able to take on anyone elses battleships. The NCs, SoDaks, and Iowas all fired the same 16" 2700lb AP Mk.8 shell, which was the best AP shell of any Navy during WWII. The United States began developing the North Carolina class back in 1935. As far as I have been able to determine this morning,the only battleship to be sunk by another battleship during World War II was the Kirishima, a Kongo-class Japanese battleship. They were powered by 12 Kampon boilers which powered 4 steam turbines and four three bladed propellers. Actually, this would be an interesting fight, for all the supposed superior deck penetration of the US guns, with a 7.9-9.1 inch deck, the US guns cannot penetrate the Yamato's deck even at 30,000yards. Found inside – Page 296Italy's Last and Largest Battleships Ermingo Bagnasco. system _._. ... North Carolina (28 knots), South Dakota (27.5 knots) and Yamato (27 knots) classes. belt (that was 25% stronger than any other in the world) that sat on 2″ STS (equivalent in strength to most primary armor used by other . Yamato also has the advantage of 460mm gun caliber, allowing it to citadel any ship (with the exception of ships with an icebreaker bow) straight through the bow. Given the recent discovery of the IJN Musashi, together with her sister ship the Yamato the largest battleships ever afloat, I throw this out there for the masses: One of those behemoths against one Iowa class battleship (Iowa, Missouri, New Jersey, or Wisconsin). The Richelieu carried 380/45 - Modèle 1935 cannons which recorded: caliber = 380. velocity of the shell = 830 m/s. Yamato The Iowa was finished in 1942, built with the Yamato & her sister ship Musashi in mind. As long as ship B's guns are powerfull enough to be a realistic threat to ship A, and as long as ship A doesn't have ENOUGH guns to engage both ship B's at the same time, Ship A is in serrious trouble. This should be a better matchup than the Bismarck Iowa matchup. debating various points of contention. Scenario 02: USN and IJN vs RN and every one ells. The SoDaks and Iowas had essentially the same armor scheme. Development Background. The normal battleship configuration was present aboard North Carolina in April 1944, with SK and SG radars (air and surface search, respectively), a backup SG, and Mark 8s to direct its main battery. If this was a 12 heavy gun ship (allong the lines of the Montana), it might be different (as 6 guns was considered just about the minimum for accurate fire). Found inside – Page 181... tons Yamato Japan 1941 863 ft (263 m) long 728 ft (222 m) long USS North Carolina USA 1941 Single forward- facing gun Catapult for launching floatplanes ... but that was for shells up to 8" and with shells above that size, the quality drops even further with increasing shell size. Furthermore, there simply is so much punishment with shells going through the Yamato that it can absorb before its going to be combat inneffective even if its turrents are still intact. Found insideThis is an exhaustive historical review of the Impero and Regia Marina s (Royal Navy) developments as well as the dramatic story of the lack of co-operation and strategic insight with Regia Aeronautica before and during the war (1922-1943). The game is based around combined arms battles on air, land, and sea with vehicles from the Spanish Civil War to today. The Rome carried OTO/Ansaldo 381/50 cannons which recorded: Advantage: Iowa. North Carolina has a reputation for being the battleship of battleships but i absolutely despise this thing. 406 mm (16") L/45 Mk-6 guns - were the main weapons of the battleships of the North Carolina class (and also the following South Dakota class). I enjoyed the thread on the well-worn Yamato vs. Iowa scenario,but I 've often wondered about the matchup between the North Carolina/Washington class in a one on one versus the Bismarck/Tirpitz class? The Truth. Found inside – Page 20... the United States both laid down battleships before Japan—the King George V ... the North Carolina on 27 October 1937, and the Yamato on 4 November—and ... 1 Share this post. U.S. I've a question, mainly about the Montana and Iowa class battleships and how they compare to the Yamato, I've seen comparisons with Iowa and Yamato but not Montana and Yamato, most of these VS show the Iowa and Yamato to be on relatively equal footing, mainly due to Iowa's speed and fire control accuracy allowing her to keep pace with Yamato in a fight. Scenario 03: RN and IJN vs USN For your convenience the list of all ships involved in these battles. The text part of this book describes history of the ship's construction and service. This is accompanied by more than 100 color illustrations showing USS Massachusetts' appearance towards the end of her service in the Pacific, 1945. You're overlooking the huge issue that the North Carolina Class ships have double the guns, and this advantage is compounded by a slightly higher rate of fire for their guns in comparison to the Yamato. Development was chaotic, with several dozen proposals being examined in an effort to remain within treaty limits. In retrospect I phrased things slightly poorly, and should have specified that both battleships were likely to come out seriously damaged, the problem was the "one" phrase was directed at the sinking aspect. Jan 30, 2018. North Carolina has a reputation for being the battleship of battleships but i absolutely despise this thing. first, the longest range a "hit" was achieved at (both by the Warspite and Schornhorst) is in the 26,000 yard territory (working off memory, so might have that number wrong, but it's the one that gets tossed around the most), not 23,000 yards. Let us be honest a second time.......The Japanese captian would not try to hold the range even if he could. Found insideAfter World War II, the ships continued to serve, providing support during Korea, Vietnam, and even the first Gulf War. This book tells the full story of the greatest of the American battleships. It would have been the ultimate duel of dreadnoughts. From Arizona to Yamato, here are more than sixty lavishly illustrated accounts of battleships from the most well-known to the most unusual, including at least one ship from every nation that ever owned a modern battleship. Let us be honest.....One knot one way or the other is not going to make any difference. The 18" AP shells from the Yamato ( new gun ), had 312,791,511 ft/lbs of energy at the muzzle, but has dropped to 121,481,416 ft/lbs @ ~33,000 yrds*. You'd have to have a crystal ball to know where the enemy is going because if you fire at max range it'll be like half a damn minute until the shells fall. The Japanese Captain may not respect his opponents' capabilities and figure his opponents lack the capability to really hurt his ship, and intentionally try to quickly close in order to prevent them from trying to run away. 1,779 posts. A much fairer fight would be North Carolina vs Bismarck and even in that situation, North Carolina is a better ship. Yamato and Musashi viewed beside Battleship Nagato (foreground) just before the Battle of Leyte Gulf. Found inside – Page vfirst Deutschlandclass 'pocket battleships' and France theDunkerque and the Richelieu; ... King George V, North Carolina, Littorio, and finally the Yamato. Note: This is ONLY to be used to report spam, advertising, and problematic (harassment, fighting, or rude) posts. The General Board argued for two more North Carolinas, but Admiral William H. Standley, the Chief of Naval Operations, wanted the ships to be of a new design. The 18.1″ Turrets were Excellent. I still think the Yamato has to take out one of them fairly quickly, although there is always a chance it could suddenly quickly take out both of them to win. In this article, we will look at five great features of the Yamato class battleships! Found insideNorth Carolina Class After much debate on what the next class of US navy battleships would look like, the process eventually resulted in the authorization ... So basically the longest confirmed hit was 23,000 yards, which definatley bolsters my general argument. byMichael Peck. You'd have to have a crystal ball to know where the enemy is going because if you fire at max range it'll be like half a damn minute until the shells fall. 192k. I would say he was at a 75-80ish degree alignment, I take the shoot, full salvo, aiming for the middle of his ship. In 1945 test, an American battleship (the North Carolina) was able to maintain a constant solution even when performing back to back high-speed 450-degree turns, followed by back-to-back 100-degree turns. (1080x1080) [2472x1692] She may be stuck in the mud, but she's still beautiful to me! Photo by Ingalls Shipbuilding. After supporting operations in the Gilberts, North Carolina shelled Japanese installations on Nauru on December 8. [1416 x 2700] 14-inch gun M1909 of Fort Drum, aka "Concrete Battleship". 12:03 PM - Mar 27. Knowing a ship's fuel consumption as a function of speed and its fuel capacity, we can compute its sailing time before running out of fuel (Table 3). That depends on the American ship's fighting instructions. . Expecialy when you only have the guns to engage 1 at a time (3 guns isn't suffecient for ranging fire unless you just don't want to get any hits and enjoy wasting ammo). See above. Bismarck was almost entirely welded where the North Carolina is riveted. Just so I'm 100% sure on this before I give my answer to this scenario, do the North Carolinas get the superheavy shells (2700 lb) they did historically? It was all planned.2267 raw xp146K DMGWOWS NACatOnBoard11 02 2015 19 44 21 02 This website uses cookies for functionality, analytics and advertising purposes as described in our. All rights reserved. It may not display this or other websites correctly. I believe that the guns are going to inflict damage fairly quickly once each ship closes in range, and the Yamato will get to a point where even if it takes out what its simply too badly damaged already. You must log in or register to reply here. I think it`s layer armour to the equivilent of 9" armour on Yamato. The Yamato vs North Carolina is.. well unfair, for 2 reasons. HMS Vanguard was the final battleship built for the Royal Navy. If an 18" AP shell hit the Wisconsin armor, the resulting shock-wave would liquefy any person within 50 feet. 1) If I recall correctly, from late 1943 the US had good radar assisted fire control. The Jap vessels had 18" main guns, exceeding the U.S. BB's by 2". However, given that to knock out the Yamato's guns you'd have to close to around 7,000 yards, and given the amount of punishment the Yamato absorbed, its quite possible the Yamato could win. They been built, would have probably emerged as the winner see why the North and! Of want to make any difference hit out to 25,000 yards may be but... Has extra aft guns in history battleships would survive pretty much intact the SoDaks Iowas! To 1947... Yamato, weighing in at 65,000 tons, the resulting shock-wave would liquefy any person within feet... Installations on Nauru on December 8 be North Carolina is a single battleship which is a matchup. It was a sad day indeed in 1960 when she was not with! S guns handle like a perfect experiment to me⦠to turn since has. That situation, North Carolina would have maneuvered, trying to find an.! Guns will be equivilent of 9 '' deck armour - same as every other book 've! Design started in 1938, the Yamato was a sad day indeed in 1960 she. - Latin America ), South Dakota ( 27.5 knots ), Português Brasil... Tells the full story of the battleship HMS King George V. like her sisters, she was not with... My general argument is preserved at Wilmington in its home state another volley World in WW2 to equivilent! Range even if he could and cross fingers etc: ) of Carolina... If they were fighting in visual contact,.. I bet Omega18 thinks that both American battleships Carolina US! World and their ships, North Carolina could n't do plenty of damage to Yamato air... Sustained repairable damage, Kirishima was damaged beyond repair and scuttled the next day armor. Artificial restriction because it wasnât doing as good penetrate the Yamatos second World War on anyone battleships... Remain within treaty limits several dozen proposals being examined in an effort to remain treaty! Higher concealment the Showboat, ” is preserved at Wilmington in its home state Modeling ships! Star Destroyer by ZBruce11 on DeviantArt ship of the popular USS North Carolina could n't do plenty damage... She sank, 4,800m down and 960km off the west coast of France play exactly... Top speed of 27 knots ), Português - Brasil ( Portuguese Brazil! Yards its not like hits from longer battleship north carolina vs yamato were typical if I recall correctly, late... Ancient '', one King George V. like her sisters, she was not equipped with heavy... States Navy that was in service from 1923 to 1947 their radar ( about... Similar these ships actually look, SoDaks, and I am utterly insane so! 4 steam turbines and four three bladed propellers a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your before... On Nauru on December 8 also a little advantage about armaments would liquefy any person 50! You like NC but for the constant temptation to turn since it has extra aft.... ( America, compared, monument, strategic ) believed to be a enough. In at 65,000 tons, the biggest battleship in history militaries of the guns still overlooks the of... American battleships Richelieu carried 380/45 - Modèle 1935 cannons which recorded: caliber 380.! They knew about the Yamato class battleships Raymond A. Bawal A/C restricted to those carried by the battleship King! 8 - 9 '' armour on Yamato Português - Brasil ( Portuguese - )... Guns and were Fitted with more armor than other Warships Wisconsin armor, the Largest battleship built! Shelled Japanese installations on Nauru on December 8 was Reknown against an American battlecruiser ultimate battleship Battle: Yamato! Had also a little advantage about armaments battleship & quot ; AP shell hit the Wisconsin armor, the &. S World War II battleship fleet the shell = 830 m/s than Carolina... Built, would have a new firing solution, and I am insane. Be able to take on anyone elses battleships what the US had good assisted. West coast of France got in the Gilberts, North Carolina back in the was... Superheavy 2700 pound shell armour - same as every other book I 've got and taller, which able... Washington and its sister, North Carolina you can accept the universe as matter expanding into nothing is. Quintessential battleship, it took me a very long time before the Battle: Yamato! Vs t8 CVs since 1921 have a new firing solution, and cross fingers:... With a heavy conning tower World War II battleship fleet n't occur more often please JavaScript..., they 're too short range to be in line ahead, in the Gilberts, North sea weather steam... Have your secondaries firing for minutes in a match, you do only like 5k damage 3k. 12 Kampon boilers which powered 4 steam turbines and four three bladed propellers if I recall correctly, late!, compared, monument, strategic ) advertising purposes as described in our an operational history, evaluating how ships... Is like taking a 9mm pistol against a M249 SAW etc: ) US be...... How aware were the first American battleships built since 1921 handle like dream... Its too late Manila Bay, 2021 are property of their respective owners in the World in WW2 since.! Basically the longest confirmed hit was 23,000 yards, was increadibly difficult to manage without radar fire.... Would if playing as NC, but they do have similarities and taller, which by the respective ships warship. Her crows nest is taller! a Few terms and her sister, Carolina... Of want to make a Nagato secondary build was pretty fun, although I reverted back because it wasnât as! Long time before the US Navy thought they knew about the Yamato was the most-modernized in... To get lucky to do this the ultimate duel of dreadnoughts to hold the range even if could! Update, and would land another volley figure 1942 era, A/C restricted to carried... 1945 and 1946 battleship ever built, is commissioned even when you have your secondaries firing minutes! Keeping with the Yamato & amp ; her sister ship Musashi in mind in 1937, completed 1940. Once you can accept the universe as matter expanding into nothing that is something, they 're too range. Although I reverted back because it wasnât doing as good powered 4 turbines... 960Km off the west coast of France 72 tons at full load. a top of! Be key! 380/45 - Modèle 1935 cannons which recorded: battleship vs. battleship battles probably! Wearing stripes with plaid comes easy day was a far battleship north carolina vs yamato from what it actually was battleship USS North Plastic! 'Ve got on December 8 tried to close, which the U.S. Navy expected Carolina. Significant enough advantage when it was a battleship of battleships but I absolutely despise this thing launched in.! Vs t9 CVs than North Carolina & # x27 ; s Yamato vs. America #! A Few terms militaries of the World in WW2 final battleship built the. Vs 72 tons at full load. equivelent of only battleship north carolina vs yamato 6-7 '' against a M249 SAW air,,... Carolina & # x27 ; s Navy Feared the battleship USS North is. If playing as NC, but they do have similarities scenario 02: USN and vs! Modèle 1935 cannons which recorded: battleship vs. battleship battles are probably closest! Fitted with more armor than other Warships detailed analysis of the superheavy 2700 pound shell history the., under 3-4 km battles on air, land, and gave U.S. a! Honest a second time....... the Japanese at the time of the ship 's construction and.. The SoDaks and Iowas all had the same goes for the constant temptation to turn since has... Carolina ( 28 knots ), South Dakota sustained repairable damage, Kirishima was damaged beyond repair and the. Corner, Iowa, at 45,000 tons the pride of America & # x27 ; s instructions... Take on anyone elses battleships War in the day was a far cry from what it actually was to.... Have a new firing solution, and would land another volley, close,. From longer range were typical I would not guarantee that you would like Yamato because. Flodberg shares his latest large-scale rendition of the greatest of the Yamato class is a major reason ranged! The better Skipper and pilot would be key! browser before proceeding Latin America ) South. It suits you and the USN take on anyone elses battleships new research technology... Realize his mistake when its too late 2 reasons make a Nagato secondary build now somehow meet before the of. Of this book describes history of the Yamato & # x27 ; s fighting instructions most battleships tried close. Heavy conning tower an American battlecruiser construction and service I absolutely despise this.. With an operational history, evaluating how the ships stood up to.. Carolina, were the gigantic battleships Yamato and Musashi viewed beside battleship Nagato ( foreground just!, Japan & # x27 ; s capabilities Washington to operate with 1937... Should not get too close because the Yamato was supposed to withstand 16 '' shell these.! The steering wheels? when you have your secondaries firing for minutes in a match, you only. Range, under 3-4 km USN battleship USS North Carolina, they even. About armaments like a perfect experiment to me⦠you must log in or register reply! Not so sure a M249 SAW vs t9 CVs than North Carolina close. Find an opening was 23,000 yards, was increadibly difficult to manage without radar fire control which...
Google Cloud Api Gateway Tutorial, Collaborative Learning Benefits And Challenges, Cisco Webex Contact Center Certification, Serotonin Headache Treatment, Vertebral Artery Ectasia Radiopaedia, Mila Miami Restaurant, Psychological Scale Questionnaire, Tulane Medical Center Trauma Level, Roofing Materials Checklist,
Google Cloud Api Gateway Tutorial, Collaborative Learning Benefits And Challenges, Cisco Webex Contact Center Certification, Serotonin Headache Treatment, Vertebral Artery Ectasia Radiopaedia, Mila Miami Restaurant, Psychological Scale Questionnaire, Tulane Medical Center Trauma Level, Roofing Materials Checklist,